How to Get the Achievement Pie in Return of the Boogeyman

Pie is an achievement in the game Return of the Boogeyman. Due to it being a visual novel, all you have to do to get this achievement is progress the game.

Pie Achievement

There’s a moment in Return of the Boogeyman where the game stops being about fear and starts being about defiance.

And it’s the sexiest thing this engine has ever rendered.

The achievement description reads: “Hot apple pie, just like boys like it.” Which is either a wink at American Pie or a declaration that this game has absolutely zero shame about what it’s doing. Probably both. Either way, Pie is the achievement where Natalie stops running, stops freezing, stops chanting it’s not real — and looks the boogeyman in his burning eyes and dares him.

Here’s the setup: He dragged her out of the tub. She’s naked, dripping, shivering, held upright by one massive clawed hand around her arm. Her platinum hair plasters itself to her face. Her body is bare — those large round breasts, that narrow waist, that shaved bare pussy, all of it exposed and pressed against the bark-rough heat of his chest. He’s furious. She’s trying to leave. Trying to erase him. And he is not a creature that tolerates being forgotten.

He presses her against the nearest surface — and his cock, hard and long and ridged and radiating heat like a furnace, pushes against her entrance.

And she refuses.

Not her body — her body is already responding, already wet, already aching. She refuses to submit. She looks up at that massive, hunched form, that single red coal of an eye, and she says it:

“Make me never forget you again.”

Steps to Earning the Pie Achievement

Step 1: This triggers during the confrontation after the Hot Bath / Ghost sequence. The boogeyman and Natalie are at a stand-off. Not long after, his cock presses against her entrance.

Step 2: We tell him “Make me remember” — the defiant option. The one that sounds like a threat and reads like an invitation.

Step 3: Watch the beautiful animated scene of the boogeyman thrusting his cock into Natalie’s pussy as they stare into each other’s eyes, and earn your Pie achievement.

She dared him. And the boogeyman — this massive, ancient, patient thing that has waited sixteen years — accepts the dare. He pushes inside her. Not gently. Not slowly. He takes her — fills that tight, bare pussy with every ridged, burning inch of his cock — and she takes it because she asked for it, because she demanded it, because she’d rather be ruined than forgotten.

The pie in the achievement name isn’t metaphorical. The game is telling you exactly what this is — hot, sweet, American-as-fuck, and served raw. He fucks her like she’s something to be consumed. Like her defiance is the crust and her wet cunt is the filling and he’s been starving for three weeks.

And she doesn’t look away. Not once. That’s the detail that makes Pie different from every other intimate achievement in this game. She keeps her eyes open, keeps them on those red eyes. She meets every thrust with her hips and every rumble with her own sound and she does not break.

Instead, she begs him to make it unforgettable.

And he does.

Pie is the achievement that turns the victim into the challenger. The prey into the dare. The girl who ran into the woman who looked at the monster and said is that all you’ve got?