How to Get the Achievement Stars in Return of the Boogeyman

Stars is an achievement in the game Return of the Boogeyman. Due to it being a visual novel, all you have to do to get this achievement is progress the game.

Stars Achievement

Every achievement in Return of the Boogeyman has a flavor. Hot Bath is grief. Ghost is rage. Pie is defiance. And then there’s Stars — the one where the boogeyman stops playing games and decides to make sure no one else will ever be enough again.

The achievement description reads: “He loves ’em all, but the black star is his favorite!” Which is the kind of line that sounds like a sticker on a bedroom wall until you’ve played this game and understand that “stars” are holes, “black” is the one he’s about to destroy, and “favorite” means he’s going to bottom out in her asshole until she forgets her own name.

Talk about an inspirational quote.

This is the achievement where the boogeyman stops punishing and starts claiming permanently.

Steps to Earning the Stars Achievement

Step 1: Stars triggers during the intimate sequence after Pie. Natalie has already dared him. He’s already fucked her pussy — hard, deep, punishing — and she’s already come once with her eyes open and her jaw clenched and her hips meeting his. She thinks that’s the punishment. She thinks she’s taken the worst he has.

She’s wrong.

Step 2: Natalie remains breathless, still trembling, still pressed against whatever surface he’s got her on — she doesn’t care to acknowledge tub to floor to bed. Instead, we hit him with our sultriest look.

Step 3: The boogeyman’s response is a rumble so deep it cracks something in the room. He flips her over. The achievement route locks in.

He’s done with her pussy. He’s done being fair. He wants the hole she’s never given anyone — the one that means something different, something permanent. The black star. His favorite.

He presses the head of his cock against her asshole — hot, broad, slick with her cum — and he doesn’t ask. Doesn’t wait. He pushes in.

Then bottoms out.

[The achievement drops here.]

And he fucks her hard. He ruins her. Long, deep, punishing thrusts that make her whole body jerk forward and her voice crack into sounds that don’t have words. Each stroke grinds against places inside her that make her vision blur and her thighs shake and her pussy drip down her legs because her body doesn’t know the difference between destruction and devotion anymore.

He’s bottoming out in her asshole because that’s what favorite means. That’s what permanent means. He’s not just fucking her — he’s making sure that every man who comes after him, every human cock that ever enters this hole, will feel like nothing. Like a placeholder. Like a shadow of the thing that actually claimed her.

He’s ruining her for everyone. On purpose. With intent.

And Natalie — bare-skinned, platinum-haired, defiant, reckless Natalie — takes every thrust and pushes back for more.

Stars is the achievement that says: he loves every hole, but this one? This one he’s keeping.